Where I would turn

Marco Scutaro Statistics and History – Baseball-Reference.com.

Scutaro has always been a favorite of mine. He’s coming off sort of a career year (in that he slugged a career-high .423) but one in which he misssed nearly fifty games. He’s a good player who meets the Braves’ needs — he has pretty good on-base skills and is a solid glove, if not what he was a few years ago. He’s signed for one more year. He is from, yes, Venezuela. I think that the Red Sox would let him go relatively cheap. And he’s not Alex Gonzalez or Jack Wilson.

Fire away.

150 thoughts on “Where I would turn”

  1. Good glove/no hit SS are a dime a dozen. Re sign Gonzalez or an equivelent then get a dang left fielder that can hit. We need offense. Jurrjens should be traded for an outfielder.

  2. If we get him we would need to add a power bat to the OF. He would allow us to call up Pats to play some and he can fill in for Chipper. He would make Prado expendable.

    However, if he got off to a slow start, he would be front runner the Whipping Boy

  3. Lowrie please. Switch hitter with high OBP potential and wouldnt cost much. In fact, we might be able to get Reddick and Lowrie for Jurrjens, killing 2 birds with one stone. Reddick’s a great 4th OF and would give us exactly what we need: backup at all OF spots, LH batter to compliment the RH hitting Diaz and Prado.

  4. Formerly Luis Valdez turned Jairo Asencio is lights out once again in Winter Leagues: 8.1 IP 0.00ERA 13K 4saves

    I feel bad for guys like this that get stuck in our system due to poor performance during callups with extremely small sample sizes. He and Cory Gearrin might never pitch for the Braves again. Can’t we just give them to the Pirates?

  5. @7

    They should both be pitching in the Braves bullpen next season, in my opinion. Both were excellent in AAA this season, have strengths that should translate to the majors, and will probably be better than whatever overpriced veteran Wren convinces himself he needs (for a recent example: see Linebrink, Scott).

    Also, I like Scutato as well. But he’s set to make, what, $5.5 million?

  6. I agree he’s the best of a lot of imperfect options. My main concern would be how much the Red Sox want in return for him. With Lowrie’s injury history, they’ve no reason to make a deal, and therefore have all the leverage in a negotiation.

  7. I get the sense that the Braves have decided that Gonzalez is not coming back – even at a bargain price. Is that correct?

    If so, Scutaro would certainly work for a year. A solid glove and decent OBP would be fine at that position for this team.

    Just don’t think Prado in LF is the answer. Great utilityman, but not what we need in left. Why is this so hard?

  8. I’d rather have Clint Barmes. Yeah, you heard me. He’s available on the free agent market and would be cheaper. His bat is above replacement level for the position and he is Gold Glove caliber with the glove. He outperformed Scutaro in both fWAR and bWAR in 2011.

  9. Not too sure about Barmes. His career slash line away from his hitter haven home parks is .230/.276/.361. If that doesn’t look familiar, it should.

  10. Grady Sizemore at 90% is probably better than any LF option we have. Question is: can we reasonably expect him to be 90%?

    Bourn
    Sizemore
    Chipper
    Uggla
    McCann
    Freeman
    Heyward
    Scutaro / Wilson / Pastornicky
    Pitcher

    Not bad. Leans too heavily on Chipper and Sizemore being healthy, but not bad.

    And (big AND) we haven’t traded away any of our pitching depth.

  11. I think the Braves will offer arbitration to Gonzalez. (My understanding is they’ll get a draft pick if declined).
    If Gonzalez accepts, they have their ss for 1 year, which is not a bad outcome. If not, they can look for trades, such as Scutaro. The fact that most of the rest of the NL East could be looking for a ss could complicate things. Gonzalez, or Scutaro could be fits for the Phillies. I’d be very surprised if the Phils are willing to give Rollins 4 or 5 years.

  12. It has been interesting to see Theo Epstein sign a series of Mac’s guys, particularly Mike Cameron and Marco Scutaro. Scutaro is definitely a far better hitter than AAG and Jack Wilson, and a worse fielder, though on balance his edge in hitting is greater than his deficiency in fielding. He would be a perfect placeholder for a year, if we could get him for $1.5 million or so.

    That said, I’m not morally opposed to a year of Jack Wilson or AAG batting #8. If we have $1.5 million to spend, I want to see it spent above slot in the draft.

  13. @17

    Yeah, MLB Trade rumors noted that the Rockies might try and flip him for Prado.

    DOB is the mouth piece of the front office.

  14. I can certainly see Auburn losing, but goodness, they have acquitted themselves pretty well through a brutal schedule, with a road win over SC that beat GA in Athens.

  15. @9, The Red Sox have very good reason to make a deal. They need upgraded SP, and they have quite the surplus at SS. That they have Scutaro, Lowrie, Aviles, and even Iglesias if he emerges means that they could even afford to deal one of them for less-than-market-value and not worry over it too much. Not that they would, just that they could.

    My tweet to DOB about Sox SS surplus went unanswered.

  16. #15–I agree that offering arbitration to Gonzalez is an attactive option. At worst, they pick up a draft pick and find someone to play SS until either Pastornicky or Simmons is ready. Gonzalez would certainly fit the bill if he stays. The Braves could then focus their efforts on an LF….

  17. #22
    Not that the visiting school in this series ever needs extra motivation, but that’s some genuine bulletin-board material.

    FWIW, I would’ve figured UGA to be about a 6.5-point fave, assuming that Isaiah Crowell plays & Malcolm Mitchell doesn’t. I don’t think the Dogs will rack up the points like Clemson, Arkansas or LSU did.

    If I’m Auburn, I gamble on stopping the run, discouraging Crowell & waiting for the big mistake from #11. If Murray plays a complete game & hits all the percentage passes, good for him. I see something like 21-16 UGA.

    Still, nothing ever surprises me in this series. An Auburn win certainly wouldn’t.

  18. I saw the Meat Puppets a couple days ago, and remembered Ububba telling me about seeing them back in the old days, playing their freaked-out country punk to Black Flag fans. Curt Kirkwood is a guitar god. It was one of the best rock shows I’ve seen in years. I feel lucky I got to see them.

  19. At worst, they pick up a draft pick and find someone to play SS

    At worst he accepts and is your starting SS plus gets a raise.

  20. If we keep A-Gon (or Wilson), it has to be under the premise that we upgrade the rest of the team sufficient so that he never bats anywhere but 8th or 9th.

    And maybe it’s just because I grew up thinking that Jerry Royster was the best you could expect out of a utility guy, but I really see Prado as an essential component for 2012 as a super-utility guy. As Chipper insurance alone…

  21. I agree that I don’t want Wilson as an everyday SS. If Pastornicky was ready I wouldn’t mind having Wilson come off the bench, but from Wren’s comments I don’t think that will be the case. You get about the same fielding with Wilson as AAG and you may get a little better BA/OBP with no power. Not a bad late inning replacement and spot starter, but nothing more.

  22. Just a word about Paterno: it’s very easy for people to be sanctimonious about what he should have done or what they would have done in a similar situation. But, it might not be so easy if it’s someone you have worked with and been friends with for, I guess, 30 years or something. I’m not saying Paterno didn’t screw up and what Sandusky did is despeccable. But people are awfully quick to show their rightous indignation when they aren’t involved.

  23. @32

    Maybe so. But the nature, frequency, and duration of the alleged crimes supersedes the usual calculus of sporting, or even personal, loyalties.

  24. Penn St board of trusties to make an announcement at 10 est.

    Here is what I want to know:

    Why is no one calling out Mike McQueary? Here is someone who saw the act taking place and did not step in. He did not go to the police. He told his boss and never followed up on it. What 28 year old man doesn’t whip Sandusky’s ass on the spot? Why is the media not going after McQueary? He is as guilty, if not more so, than Paterno.

  25. Fox TV Philly: ‘Police in riot gear are manned throughout the campus in light of the pending announcement.’

  26. Wow. This is beyond even what you could imagine regarding the end of the Paterno era.

    Oh well. Child sex abuse has to be stamped out like the plague that it is. There is no gray area. There is no “sanctimonious” as I saw mentioned above. You can’t be too “sanctimonious” when it comes to this.

  27. Am I correct in stating that the Braves allowed the fewest number of unearned runs last season? If so, Gonzalez had a lot to do with that. Can’t be too strong defensively up the middle. He’ll drive me nuts when he swings at sliders in the left-handed batter’s box, but, if he can provide another year of solid defense, I can live with his bat for one more year.

  28. Marc S, I don’t disagree with you. It is hard for me to state with moral certitude that I would have done the right thing when confronted with unspeakable horror in the center of a cult of personality. So if I’m honest, I should be humble about my failings and hope that I would have the courage to do the right thing.

    That said, it’s pretty hard not to have a great deal of moral indignation about this. This is about as unambiguous a case of evil since Kevin Ricks.

  29. Yeah, the charge of sanctimoniousness should be saved for a situation containing a little more moral ambiguity. Any horse that gets your feet out of the muck is the high horse here.

  30. I completely agree with Marc. No one is excusing anything anyone did, but to think it’s not possible for someone (especially someone as old as Paterno) to convince themselves that their old, trusted friend isn’t really a child rapist is absurd.

  31. My father — who is a few years younger than Paterno was at the time — says that in that situation he doesn’t think he could have done more than Paterno did.

  32. That’s quite different from acknowledging that, especially given the repercussions, not doing more constitutes a fireable offense.

  33. Happy 236th birthday, Marines. God bless America and the United States Marine Corps. Semper fidelis.

  34. Poythress Day. Literally no idea where he’ll sign. Could be any of the four. Remarkable how secretive he’s been able to stay.

  35. I think the trustees had to get rid of Paterno. But no one actually knows what they would do in a given situation. History shows that people-even otherwise good people-are capable of almost anything under the right circumstances. Paterno should have done more, but it’s not as if he raped those kids himself. People are complaining that Paterno put friendship over his moral obligation, but ask yourself if you wouldn’t be conflicted if you were told about something a three-decades old friend did.

  36. I think they should’ve let him finish out the season. Obviously, no one is blameless, but the guy put 60 years of his life into the university, and did report the crime to his superiors. I agree he has to go, but a few more games isn’t changing anything, and that type of service should count for something.

  37. You think the PSU board wants to see Joe carried off the field after his last home game before being forced to retire for harboring a predator? Or the certain protest, counter-protests, and potential for violence over the next three games? Joe told them to f off with his little “You can’t fire me, I quit, p.s., not for another month plus a bowl game” stunt. Having him take the field would have been a complete disaster.

  38. Marc at 62,

    I acknowledge that turning in a friend to go to jail could be difficult, but there were ohter things that Paterno could have and should have done:

    1. Confront Sandusky and tell him to (a) not come on campus again and (b) not to continue to be arond young boys OR ELSE Joe WOULD go to police.

    2. Follow up with the AD and push instead of be passive.

    I have since this first broke on Saturday morning suspected that Paterno had much more kknowledge than what has yet to be revealed officially. I remember specifically (not the year, but the rough time line) Sandusky going from being the “designated heir apparent” to “retired and out of here.” It smelled VERY suspicious then.

  39. Joe absolutely had to go.
    He is not going to be the last head that rolls in this either. Penn State is going to get hammered when more info comes out, and there is always much more to the story.

    If that link from Spike proves to be real we need some public executions for all involved.

    Prado for Seth Smith is another horrible thought.

  40. It’s already a complete disaster; firing JoePa doesn’t change that. If he were charged w/a crime, or even being investigated, I could see it, but he’s not.

    Yes, he should’ve done more, but weighing everything, I think they should’ve let him finish the season. In no way do I discount the monstrosity that occurred, but firing him doesn’t change that, and IMO, the past six days shouldn’t count more than the past 60 years.

  41. I get the picture of them all sitting around the big screen in Hell and just horselaughing everybody and slapping themselves on the back.

    The chain reaction of evil is amazing at times.

  42. The university could not allow Paterno to continue to represent the school for one more day. Having Paterno coach any more games sends the twisted signal that the school cares more about football than it does about the victims of this abuse. Until yesterday, Paterno & the school seemed tone-deaf to the bigger issue here.

    Paterno obviously did a lot of good for the school, but his apparent culpability in this episode is just too horrible to consider any upside. I’m sorry, I can’t cut the old man any slack on this one.

  43. You think the PSU board wants to see Joe carried off the field after his last home game before being forced to retire for harboring a predator? Or the certain protest, counter-protests, and potential for violence over the next three games? Joe told them to f off with his little “You can’t fire me, I quit, p.s., not for another month plus a bowl game” stunt. Having him take the field would have been a complete disaster.

    Bingo. The trustees were faced with one of two possibilities. The fanbase booing Paterno and themselves turning on the team/administration, which would only further highlight the absurdity of their not firing him. Or, more likely, the team/fans rallying around Paterno with a “me against the world” mentality. But the problem in that circumstance is obvious: because the rest of the world is outraged by child rape, the Penn State community would look like it was rallying behind… child rape. And that would be a complete PR (and moral) disaster.

    Ethan, it is already a disaster, but it can get much, much worse. Leaving aside, for a moment, our personal feelings on the matter, further administrative inaction or (worse) a positive defense of Paterno would make the current outcry look timid. This was a fait accompli as soon as the news broke on Saturday.

    If that link from Spike proves to be real we need some public executions for all involved.

    Yes! Absolutely! We (by which I guess we mean the government? the NCAA? Braves Journal?) absolutely should execute people on national television, because nothing cleanses the soul quite like the spectacle of death.

  44. They harbored this guy. They didn’t just ignore it. They permitted it.

    After mothers complained, he was investigated in 1998 for showering with boys, and touching them.

    So they forced him to retire.. a year later.

    But they kept him around. They brought him to bowl games, and let him bring little boys with him.. They permitted him to use the football facilities for his ‘Troubled Kids’ program.

    In 2000, he was caught by a janitor, performing oral sex on a little boy. Two years after they already knew he fondled little boys in the shower.

    He was caught sodomizing an 11 year old boy in the shower, in 2002. The university already knew he was fondling boys in 1998, and performing oral sex on them in 2000.

    They continue to let him use the facilities, and run the Second Mile program, for TEN MORE YEARS.

    They did everything they could to protect this guy. They everything they could to protect Penn State. And they did it at the expense of his victims.

  45. Jesus fucking christ. One of my oldest friends was arrested this morning for exploitation. I am so unbelievably sad.

  46. @65 and 70

    Dead on. It is like ripping and bandaid off. It stings, but you have to do it.

    No one can tell me that Joe Paterno didn’t know more than they say. This guy is the most powerful person at the school and in the town. He didn’t get that way by being a cute dumb old man.

    Someone with his clout could have done more. He made a mistake by not doing more. He knows that now. Sometimes mistakes have repercussions. His mistake did.

    In the long run, I hope we can remember JoePa for all the good things he did.

  47. I feel for you, Spike.

    I found out, many years after the fact, that the best baseball coach I ever had went to jail for the same offense. There’s just nothing good about these stories.

  48. The more I read about the Penn State riot last night, the more floored I get. I am almost at a loss for words for how twisted those students were being–for how stupid, short-sighted, and uncompassionate they are to have rioted in the name of their coach, but not, of course, for the children whose victimization he ignored.

  49. Love Scutaro, perfect fit for the Braves. Mac, why are you not in the front office?

    Penn State, worst thing ever.

  50. I haven’t been following as closely as it seems that many of you have. How is McQueary still on staff?

  51. Good riddance: the more we find out about Penn State the worse it looks. The Board certainly did the correct thing and one day many of the angry students will understand their rationale.

    Nonetheless, Paterno’s reputation will not recover–and it probably shouldn’t. He has long been past his sell by date–his ability to coach into his 80s demonstrated ego, arrogance, lack of accountability and almost certainly a growing lack of judgement.

    We will never know, but had he retired at a normal age, a number of abuses might not have occurred: a younger more alert coach would probably have been around and been able to act, when Paterno–almost Ahab like in his insistence on remaining head coach–so clearly failed.

    My guess is that the narrative is just beginning to develop, but it is hard to see how Penn State will recover its reputation in the near future.

    As someone involved with university administration, I feel terrible not only for the boys who suffered, but all of those who have attended Penn State. Despite this awful scandal, we should not forget how many good things take place on university campuses like Penn State everyday….

  52. #88
    Nice, but jeez…

    #85
    A civil attorney advising and/or representing victims makes a public statement criticizing some of the very people he or the victims probably intend to sue? Shocking.

  53. Payback for all the “Li’l Jonny” cracks, most likely.

    Ethan, your point about Paterno is well taken, and to some extent I agree. But he’s had a full and rewarding career, and concepts like “legacy” and “on whose terms” are sometimes subject to the Tough Sh** Rule.

  54. #87

    That goes some way towards my question as to whether Posnanski is the right guy to write the new book. I’ll give him the break that he was in a confined space with students who are taking not Joe Paterno’s class, but the freaking Joe Paterno Class. They probably still had scratches and burn marks, and he may have feared for his safety…..

  55. Paterno isn’t Tressel. He passed the information he received to the people who were supposed to handle the situation as part of their jobs.

    Meanwhile, the guy who saw a kid being raped and didn’t intervene still has his position. Thankfully, I’ve never been in that situation, but I can’t imagine not saying something on the spot. I’m pretty sure my gut reaction would be some kind of exclamation, not just walking away.

  56. Question: If the Braves are raising the payroll, then why are they interested in shedding payroll by trading Jurrjens and Prado? Is Wren trying to make a move for a high-salary player?

  57. #95 – Paterno turned his head to a child predator and kept letting the guy hang around the campus for 12 years. He did only a small part of what he should have done. He couldve kept kids from being harmed by this clown, but he put it off and wanted to let someone else handle what he couldve easily done himself. That doesnt get you off the hook IMO.

  58. If I’m in Paterno’s shoes, I pass the information to people who determine how credible the report is and possibly start an investigation. If nothing happens, I probably assume that either the grad student was exaggerating or that there’s nothing that can be done.

    Let’s think about it this way. What if McQueary was lying? If Paterno did more than what he did, he’d be vilified for that instead. The first thing to do is figure out what happened, so he passed the information to people in a position to do that. It’s their responsibility to handle the situation, and they’re being brought up on charges for not doing it. I don’t want a football coach acting like a judge and jury.

  59. As a parent, if I know something like that is happening to any child then I have to report that to authorities. Forget my title or what other people around me can or cant do. I, have to do that for the kids who are being harmed and to make sure no one else can be a victim.

    Joe is just as guilty as the people in the administration. None of them upheld their responsibilities.

  60. My sources tell me Poythress to Kentucky. Now just win on Saturday and the official “Stick it to Vandy” week is complete.

  61. @100, I could live with that, had there been any meaningful effort on Paterno’s part to know about the ensuing effort to find out what happened. It bears repeating – no one even bothered to learn the name of the child. Any investigation that didn’t even bother to follow up with the victim is a sham on it’s face, and Paterno either didn’t review the findings, or didn’t care that they dropped it. No excuse.

  62. If he knew something like that was happening, he should have reported it. However, he just knew about a claim, so he passed the claim up to be investigated.

    Now any assistant coach in the country who wants to get rid of his competition knows he just has to make up a kid touching story, and the head coach will be so afraid of being JoPa’d that his rival will be out of the way.

    Advocating rash action leads to false claims which lead to actual claims being taken less seriously. The people who should have done something were the two who are charged with failure to report.

  63. @100 – The guy was investigated for suspicion of sexual child abuse back before he “retired” from Penn State. Please don’t tell me that you believe Joe Paterno did not have any knowledge of this when it was reported to him that the same thing was (allegedly) happening again on the friggin’ Penn State campus, in an athletic building.

    There should be no equivocation: at the very least, Penn State tolerated a child molester. That seems pretty clear. As more and more comes out each day, it seems like the worst could get a whole lot worse.

  64. 102—Congrats. Here’s hoping we only have to face him for one year.

    And good luck on Saturday. I believe you’re really going to need it.

  65. #104 – “Now any assistant coach in the country who wants to get rid of his competition knows he just has to make up a kid touching story, and the head coach will be so afraid of being JoPa’d that his rival will be out of the way.”

    Thats a load of crap. No one would make up a story like that, but even if they do you report it to the authorities and let them handle it.

  66. @103, yeah I see your point. The fact that the investigation hardly happened means that either they found the claim to be completely bogus, which means the grad assistant should be fired, or they were more worried about the image of the university than the safety of children. Either way, if I’m Paterno, I need to act on it.

    I wonder if he’ll explain why he didn’t pursue it, or if we’ll have to wait for the Posnanski book.

  67. I assume the alleged perv brought them there. Like, “Hey, this is where the players work out. Cool, huh? Now let me show you my penis.”

  68. Your answer begs a number of obvious questions that one would think would be asked by responsible people managing a major sports program.

  69. @66,

    Cliff,

    I’m not saying Paterno shouldn’t have done more. I’m not saying he shouldn’t be fired. It’s a horrible situation. I’m just not comfortable with people taking a easy morally superior position that is not as black and white as it seems. I admit I haven’t followed the stuff that closely, but as far as I know, Paterno didn’t actually see Sandusky doing these awful things; he was told about it. He did the minimum he needed to do legally and, certainly, he should have done more but I’m sure there was a willingness to disbelieve something like that about a friend. I’m sure he was hoping it didn’t happen and it would go away. That’s not excusing him, but it’s a pretty human reaction.

    There was clearly a failure up and down the line at PSU and these kids suffered and will continue to suffer. Paterno certainly has to share the responsibility. But people just seem too eager too pounce on the man.

    As for what someone else said about Paterno being arrogant because he kept coaching, I certainly hope that when I’m Paterno’s age, I have the desire to do something like that. Who wants to acknowledge that he is too old to do something that has been their life? Is he supposed to voluntarily leave and go sit in a rocking chair? I agree that he has not been a particularly good coach for several years, but I don’t see that as arrogance.

  70. I don’t agree with the trade/demote Prado bandwagon. Sure, the guy had a sub-par year. But he did have that leg infection. His other years he hit like a great 2nd basemen and an average corner outfielder. We have a 2nd baseman who hits like a corner outfielder, so we can live with a corner outfielder who hits like a 2nd baseman.

  71. I’m hoping that Posnanski uses this opportunity to actually tell this story. He’s got a front-row seat, and he has access to the Paternos that no one else will be able to touch, now that Paterno’s legacy has literally melted overnight. Posnanski can certainly tend toward the maudlin, but he is a good reporter, and I just hope that he can perform the necessary mental gymnastics to see that his entire story has been pulled out from under him. He’s the writer best positioned to tell the true story of Joe Paterno’s nearly half-century reign at Penn State, which left him one of the most successful football coaches ever, but also led to a culture in which the unspeakable happened.

    It’s a story that absolutely needs to be written. And I just hope he writes it.

  72. Let’s hold the tears for Paterno until we figure out whether the allegations in the link spike posted @63 are true, shall we? Because if they are true, Paterno is going to jail for covering up the abuse, his career and all the stuff he did for the university are all but meaningless and McQueary, though still not exactly a hero (he still should’ve broken up the assault, obviously) becomes much more of a whistleblower-type figure. There’s more to find out here, and the last person anybody should be having any sort of sympathy for is Joe Paterno. His career was pretty much over anyway. He loses precisely nothing except for his job which he had already been grossly unqualified to hold for at least the last five years.

  73. The grad-assistant observing the child being anally raped in the player’s locker room was the THIRD report of Sandusky, ahem, “inappropriately touching” a child.

    The third time.

    Are you really going to convince yourself that Paterno didn’t hear a word about the first two? Really?

    When the third one comes around, Joe needs to be on the phone with the police. No administrator, the police.

    But they covered up for him the first time, and that gave him the leverage to keep going. Now, if they ratted on him, they implicated themselves.

    So they let it happen. Over and over again.

  74. If Happy Valley turns out to be Caligula’s Garden (as is suggested in the article linked @63), it very well may be the sickest story that ever began on the sports pages.

    Just too disgusting to be true. Right? Right?

  75. DOB teasing us with mentioning Mark Cuban as a potential buyer if and when on the market = just not right…

  76. Is there any news of when we will be on the market? I’m really ready to see the back of Liberty Media…

  77. Depends on the health of Jurrjens and Youk, but I think we lose in that deal. And I think Fat Melky played a better outfield than we can expect from Youkilis.

    I want Arthur Blank as owner of the Braves. Can you imagine …

  78. Jason Stark has us tied to Rollins…I’d like, but not for 5 years.

    Giving him Lowe’s old deal would probably end up being an overpay, but I doubt he’d sign for less…

  79. Nah, I don’t think the Poythress family was amenable to fishy stuff like that. I think Alex just decided to go where he could get his sister a volleyball scholarship (UK or Memphis), and then his dad’s preference won out over his mom’s.

  80. I’ve been a fan of Paterno and have generally respected Penn State’s program. That being said,I can see no scenario where Paterno should have kept his job. I still hope things don’t come out that make things a lot worse, but I’m not holding out hope for better news either. It is unspeakably sad and horrifying.

  81. @129

    I get where he’s coming from, for the most part. I think it’s wrong to say Paterno has been scapegoated, though, because scapegoating implies that other more culpable parties are escaping blame. Sandusky is being charged, and the AD and president of the university are out of jobs.

    Also, he was demonstrably NOT left twisting in the wind. I’m sure to Posnanski this week must seem interminable, but Paterno’s fate was officially sealed four days after the story blew up. That is an extraordinarily quick resolution, although I agree that firing him by messenger was a cowardly act.

  82. Bleacher Report –

    http://bleacherreport.com/articles/930944-2011-trade-proposal-is-jair-jurrjens-a-fit-for-the-boston-red-sox

    Highlights –

    The Best Case Scenario
    Boston sends Carl Crawford, Jed Lowrie, Bryce Brentz and Sean Coyle, with cash, to Atlanta.
    Atlanta sends Jair Jurrjens and Martin Prado to Boston.

    A More Realistic Trade
    Boston sends Jed Lowrie, Josh Reddick, Che-Hsuan Lin and Mike Aviles to Atlanta.
    Atlanta sends Jair Jurrjens and Kris Medlen to Boston.
    *Could include a “player to be named later” from Boston; possibly a lower level infield prospect such as Kolbrin Vitek, or Oscar Tejeda

  83. At least with the second option we get to keep Prado…..

    I don’t see the Bosox parting with Brentz, but he would certainly be a nice prospect to have in our system….

  84. Wren named Medlen in a group of Atlanta’s 8 starters this year. I dont see any way that we’ll trade both Medlen and JJ right now, esp after Lowe got moved.

  85. @135 absolutely right.

    I wonder though if they considered putting Paterno on leave pending the investigation. That way you are letting the legal process work without acting before you have complete information.

    Personally, I’m terribly conflicted with McCreary. Was this a kid who saw his idol, an authority figure or at least someone close to the authority figures in his life. Was he paralyzed by the utter shock and confusion of what he saw? Should he have acted differently? I can say that I would have acted differently, but do I know it?

  86. I was chatting with some of the guys at overthemonster.com (Boston sb nation site) and they don’t think Boston will touch Jurrjens because of his inabiltiy to convince SABR guys that he’s good. Boston relies heavily on advanced stats.

  87. @129, 135

    Yeah, I’m not sure he understands what scapegoating means. I also find it hard to believe that someone writing a book originally intended to be a Father’s Day present – intended to be a story of a Great Leader – should lecture anyone on “complexity.” But that’s just me, I guess.

  88. @142 – Posnanski has a pretty good record of rationally writing about complex issues and getting at the truth. Yeah, he probably had a very specific arc for his book in mind going in based on what he knew and had learned about Paterno before the scandal broke – I would have too – but I don’t doubt his ability to adjust on the fly once he has a chance to process all the facts. He’s just arguing for time to allow all the facts to come out before judgement is passed. There’s nothing wrong with that.

  89. I can see how he’s considering it as scapegoating by the volume of media and public attention/scorn that Paterno has received. But he was also the most public figure involved.

  90. @144 – Yes, ratio of media focus to actual involvement and fault (based on what’s currently known anyway) has been much higher for Paterno than anyone else involved in the case, and that’s a fair definition of scapegoating. His celebrity is certainly the reason for it, but that doesn’t change the fact that it’s happening. And pointing out that it’s happening isn’t saying anything about what he deserves. He should have done more, he should have been fired for not doing more, he’s partially responsible for anything that happened after he failed to do more, and he’s become the media’s scapegoat. Those things don’t contradict.

  91. Heavy is the head that wears the crown. Joe seemed quite willing to be the face of PSU. That means you are it for good or ill – it’s a bit late to complain now. Combine that with a fair bit of sanctimony about your program, and a massive amount of hubris about your standing relative to the crimes alleged, and you get exactly what happened. You aren’t a scapegoat if you testify that you did in fact, do what people are criticizing you for.

  92. Ten thousand media members saying Paterno fell short in his moral obligation is not scapegoating. Discussing what it means for his legacy is not scapegoating, because that’s an issue apart from assigning blame for what’s happened. Now, if there are media members saying it was all his fault, that would be scapegoating, but that’s not what I’m reading. It’s a gigantic story, it has to be addressed, and there’s not much to say about Sandusky.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *