In the Twin Cities tonight, Tyler Mahle surrendered a 2 run homer in the first, but nothing else in 6 2/3. After the rough first, Mahle looked every bit as strong as in his first two starts for Atlanta. The bullpen gave up 2 more in the 8th when Didier Fuentes uncharacteristically gave up 3 hits, including a two-rbi double. The offense only managed a solo homer from Baldwin, thus the final score of 4-1.
Should we be worried? Since the 8 game winning streak ended on August 6, our Braves have lost 7 of 11. Just last Wednesday, the lead over the Phillies was 9.5; it’s now 5.5.
What’s been the problem? It’s true that the starters haven’t kept up the phenomenal pace they were on in late July and early August. And the bullpen is not quite as sharp lately.
Still, the pitchers gave up just 4 runs in each of the two games against the Twins this week. If the Braves had scored the 4.8 runs in these two games that they’ve averaged this season, both games would have gone into the win column.
The glaring issue in this stretch is the offense. In the 10 games since the streak before tonight, the Braves on base percentage was .260. In tonight’s loss to the Twins, the Braves had 6 hits and 1 walk in 34 plate appearances, so that OBP only got worse.
Although the first three pitchers the Braves faced after August 6 were Cy Young caliber guys (the Yankees fearsome threesome), since then the opposing hurlers haven’t been guys of that pedigree. Tonight, someone named Zebby Matthews, who had an ERA of 5 and a half coming in, completely flummoxed the Braves hitters. Well, all except Baldwin (2 hits including a solo homer) and Harris (3 hits including 2 doubles).
Is faithful and long-time commenter Roger right about this team? While everyone in Braves land has expressed concern with the starting rotation (and AA’s failure to improve it in the offseason or at the deadline), Roger has consistently maintained that the offense is also a concern. Certainly the last 11 games prove that when you score 2-3 runs per game you won’t win nearly as many games as when you score 5 or more.
Or is Peter Moylan right? He insisted after the game that it’s good thing the offense is having a slow spell; they are getting it out of the way in August, so that next month they are more likely to start slugging again. I love Peter, but his relentless optimism is a little overwhelming. I think of Moylan as the bizzaro version of our regular commenter Mr. Overlords.
I incline toward optimism in my fandom, so I’m going to expect the team to start scoring runs again. Let’s do so sooner rather than later, starting tomorrow. AJ Smith-Shawver starts in a 1:40 Eastern time start. It will help the kid’s confidence (and mine) for the team to score at least 7 or 8.

They’ll be fine. Excited to see AJSS today.
I wonder if there is a generational divide between those of us who endured the ’70s and those for whom the 90’s are the expected Braves teams. I’m not sure that explains very much, but it’s hard for me personally to understand the view that management is neglecting some obvious route to World Championships to preserve capital returns. Steve Cohen certainly isn’t preserving capital returns and he has made his team a mess. The Dodgers may or may not be preserving capital returns but I don’t think anyone doubts they have a lot more money to spend… and they spend it. And as much as 1996 and 1999 sting for me personally, the Braves won a World Series 5 years ago and the Yankees are on a 16 year drought.
And the one thing I’m completely positive about is that run deviations in August are correlated with nothing. On this date in 2021, the Braves were 65-57 and up 2 games. I’d rather be 74-52 and up 5 1/2, even though that difference doesn’t mean anything for October either.
I’m positive that anyone who endured the Rowland Office Era (or even the Andres Thomas Era) will have a different perspective from anyone who grew up with Glavine/Smoltz/Maddux, or Freddie/Fried, etc.
Once a fanbase enjoys top-of-the-mountain success, a part of it becomes entitled. It’s like that in every sport.
Some teams (e.g. – Bama football, Kentucky basketball, Yankees baseball) win so much that it almost ruins any perspective a portion of the fanbase has. A certain joylessness can creep in, and it’s alienating to be around.
I’m a realist, but… I tend toward the optimistic side. Otherwise, why bother at all?
I mean, my favorite baseball team ever is still the ’91 Braves. They didn’t win their last game, but… what a thrill ride of a season. I don’t wear that last loss as a badge of honor (like pre-’04 Red Sox fans might) or as a failure (like ’24 Yankee fans might), but I sure remember that whole experience as nothing but amazing & the very reason why one pays attention at all. And yeah, enduring those lean years was a big part of why ’91 was so thoroughly exhilarating.
Hey, we’re still in 1st place, we’re on a 95-win pace & I’d be shocked if we weren’t playing in October. Beats the hell out of last year. Let’s just get over the finish line & roll the dice.
I think the team will be fine. Slumps happen, it’s baseball. I do wish the offense had more plate discipline, it would lessen these occasional slumps.
This is a fascinating look at what makes Matt Olson such a good receiver at first base, particularly on throws that are low or in the dirt:
https://www.mlb.com/news/matt-olson-among-leaders-in-new-first-base-scoops-stat
Great article. On the “wide catch radius” discussion, I remember that a bunch of Andrelton Simmons’s great plays involved him making a spectacular stop, getting rid of the ball very quickly, and throwing it hard in the general direction of first, where Freeman would fully extend to one side or another, up or down, to get the out just before the runner arrived.
That’s an awesome link and story I’d have never run into otherwise. Thanks!
Kim surely cannot be worse than Jarvis?
Oh, but he is. Even at Gwinnett Kim had a .621 OPS; Jarvis was at .868.
Should have clarified – in the field.
Honestly, the kid did a good job until those last couple batters. Even the hits in the 5th were soft, but it looked like he lost confidence and started nibbling a little.
EDIT: and then Dodd gives up the big hit. Yuck.
Crazy Twins BABIP. Death by a thousand needles. AJSS looked good until the end there.
And now Dodd removes all doubt.
The entire series was also an announcer’s jinx, as Gaudin kept blathering on about the team coming in with a 9-2 record at Target Field compared with 5-8 in the Metrodome.
And we’re back. Gotta win this game now. Lane Thomas has been a good addition.
Atop everything else, this bullpen is awful right now.
Riley is back at it – striking out with men in scoring position. Braves struck out at lease four times in the last two innings with a man on second. Braves did not lead the entire series…..
In the inning the Brave scored 3 they struck out on the last two outs and the first of the next inning for three in a row.
14 strikeouts today.
Everybody in the world can see in real time whether a pitch is a ball or a strike, except the players and the umpires. Surely 100% ABS is coming soon.
Man, Jarvis is terrible, Just play Kim for a while and see if he can do any better.
Recapped