Tonight’s game was the biggest, most important game of the season for the Braves. It may not have been a literal “must win” game; it would still be possible to make the playoffs with a loss. Possible, but barely so—the playoff hopes would be hanging by the slimmest of threads.
But with a win, you’re right back in the thick of the race, down just one game to the Mets, and no more than a game and a half behind the Diamondbacks. So, yeah, it’s hard to imagine a much bigger game.
And how did our guys respond? With maybe their best game of the season.
Let’s start with Spencer Schwellenbach. Schwelly tossed seven masterful innings, allowing just three hits and a lone run, throwing just 87 pitches. PDQ is one of the most impressive rookie pitchers I’ve ever seen. His command of multiple pitches, his demeanor, his savvy, are just extraordinary. He’s certainly one of the most improbable guys to be in this position, starring in the biggest game of the year. Y’all are aware of his extremely limited experience as a starting pitcher. I still can’t fathom how he shows such mastery of the craft.
(By the way, JonathanF, for much of this season Spencer pitched on your Fridays, causing you to give him the nickname Shabbas Schwellenbach. More recently, I’ve had the pleasure of recapping his starts on Tuesdays. If I have the Hebrew right, that would make him Shlishi Schwellenbach.)
The offense continued its recent rejuvenation. Michael Harris II led the way with a single, double, and a homer. The Big Bear also went yard, making this just the second time in Atlanta Braves history that they have hit multiple homers in seven straight games. (How did they not accomplish this feat last year?)
The Braves got on the board in the third inning. Arcia led off with slow roller down the third base line. He was going to beat it out anyway, but Severino made a wild throw that allowed Orlando to take second (catcher Alvarez deserved an assist on that error, as he ran into the pitcher as he fielded it)). A double to right by MHII scored the first run, and an opposite field ground ball single by Ozzie plated Harris. Ozzie alertly took second when the throw to the plate missed the cutoff man. Ozzie then aggressively took third on a slow grounder to short by Ozuna. Olson walked on a 3-2 pitch, so runners on the corners with one out.
But Soler struck out looking on a sweeper that caught the inside corner. (What is it with these sweepers this year? Everyone is throwing one.) Another failure to plate a runner on third with two outs. They had already stranded a runner on third in the first, and you had to wonder if once again wasted opportunities would catch up with them. But this time the luck turns! Laureano fisted a weak grounder that found its way through the right side, scoring the third run. Money Mike’s solo shot in the fourth (420 feet to the opposite field!) and El Oso Grande’s in the fifth pushed the lead to 5-0. For good measure, Harris also showed off his glove. He made a diving grab of a liner off the bat of Luisangel Acuna that Andruw Jones would have been proud of.
Five runs was a lot more than Schwellenbach needed. He was simply masterful, shutting them out until a Nimmer solo home run in the seventh. Jimenez and Iglesias did their thing in the 8th and the 9th. I’m not sure folks appreciate how terrific those two have been at the back of the pen.
So, how ‘bout them Braves! They are indeed right in the thick of a pennant race. And they have Sale and Fried lined up for the next two against the Mets. What must it be like to be a Mets fan, with memories of this time of year in 2022 fresh in their minds?
One wrinkle there. Hurricane Helene is currently forecast to bring torrential rains to Atlanta by Thursday. Given the current track of the storm, it’s hard to imagine getting the third game of this series in. But if, as seems likely, that lost game could impact playoff eligibility for either or both teams, we could be looking at a makeup next Monday.
But let’s take it one day at a time. The Braves move into a tie with the Mets, and win the season tie-breaker, with a win tomorrow behind Cy Sale.

Shabbos, shlishi… Or as Snoop would say, he’s the Shizzle.
Giants destroying the DBacks. We’ll be a half game out. It’s all right there for the taking.
MH2 played like a superstar tonight. He’s the best player on the field, and we need him to be. Good crowd, good game. Hats off to Spencer (we have the best Spencers, don’t we?). Let the record show that we actually won while I was in the park. Let’s keep it going.
You’re now our good luck charm, krussell. Make reservations for Monday just to be on the safe side.
Where did the PDQ nickname come from? I know some here have been calling him that, but I must have missed the origin. Or maybe it’s obvious and I’m oblivious…
The humorist/composer Peter Schickele created the fictional PDQ Bach, “the youngest and oddest of Johann Sebastian Bach’s twenty-odd children,” as his stage name and alter ego. There were many comedy albums and a long-running series on NPR.
Thanks. Would’ve never gotten that. Not in my world, I suppose.
I’ve got to give credit to Brian Snitker. The team has scuffled all year, and struggled to get over the hump. But they came into their biggest game of the season, with the playoffs on the line, they played a complete game on both sides of the ball and won a commanding victory.
It would be easy for the pressure to get to them. I know it would get to me, and I never expected that they’d do as well as they did last night. I think Snit is really good at keeping the guys calm, and that’s exactly what’s needed here.
Agreed. If this team stays hot and makes the playoffs, it will be hard not to give credit to Snitker, as someone who has been more critical of him this year. His pitching decisions are poor but that’s not nearly as important as keeping the players focused and playing their best when it matters.
Great win. How about Schwellenbach (or “flooded creek” which is pretty much the German translation about an “angeschwollener Bach”)?! After this game, I claim him to be German.
So, what will happen if today/tomorrow are rained out? I have read several things – moving to a different location, double-header on Monday. What’s most likely??
And this… According to BP, 50 years ago today, Tommy John had UCL surgery.
And Mr. John and spouse were interviewed this morning on Fox & Friends in celebration of that anniversary. He said effectively “I just believed in Dr. Jobe. If he had told me to collect my German Shepherd poops and bury them behind second base at Dodger Stadium, I would have done it.”
Mr tfloyd jumping in with a prompt recap. Maybe just too excited to sleep. Great job on this.
Why the MLB morons haven’t already announced moving the Thursday game up to 1:00 or so today is beyond insane. Modern hurricane modeling is very accurate. If this was 1985, maybe not.
Since it is “win or go home” I can’t fault Snit for staying with Gimenez and Iglesias, but it would have been nice to save those bullets.
Thanks, Cliff–you have that right. I’m usually too tired to do the recap right after a game is over, but I’ll admit I was pretty pumped last night.
Current forecast shows that both tonight’s and tomorrow’s games are in dire jeopardy. What in the world do they do if they can’t play either in Atlanta this week?
Playing a double-header Monday would be a disaster for both teams. Whoever advances (maybe both do?) will have their pitching all messed up and start the WC series with a disadvantage. I bet they try to get tonight’s game in and we might need to prepare to play in a steady rain all night.
If both games get washed out then at least we’ll have Sale starting against the Royals. Maybe Schwellenbach can pitch Sunday if needed.
In the meantime let’s root for an outcome where the Mets games don’t have to be played because we’ve both already clinched.
I would assume the unfortunate task of playing 1 or possibly 2 games on Monday.
Here’s a scenario…what if today and tomorrow are rained out, the Braves sweep the Royals this weekend, the Diamondbacks win 2 of their remaining 4 games, and the Mets only win 1 (or 0) of their final 3. So then you have the Braves at 89 wins, Arizona 89, and the Mets 87 or 88. Braves hold the tiebreaker over Arizona (as do the Mets). In this case, the Braves would be in, but the Mets would need to play the games out (at least 1, maybe both of them). So we could theoretically have to play on Monday even though we’re already in…
Edit – krussell said it above – we need us and the Mets to win this weekend and the Dbacks to lose, so both Braves and Mets are tied or ahead of Arizona.
Goodness, Spencer Schwellenbach gets more impressive the more I see him. What he showed last night was veteran poise. In the single biggest game of the entire season, he didn’t nibble, he went right after them, blowing upper-nineties smoke in the zone and mixing in a filthy array of sliders and cutters, with a handful of curveballs, splitters, and sinkers. (According to baseball-savant, he threw 38 four-seamers, 24 sliders, 13 cutters, 5 curveballs, 4 splitters, and 3 sinkers, ranging from an 80-mile-an-hour curveball to a 98-mile-an-hour fastball.) “Here’s my best stuff, try and hit me if you can” is exactly the mentality you want on the mound of a high-stakes game.
Here’s Savant: https://baseballsavant.mlb.com/player-scroll/game?gamePk=747068&player_id=680885#sorted
Last night was his first playoff start, and he passed with flying colors. He’s got one hell of a bright future in this league.
Nice article on Olson’s early season slump and how he turned it around.
good article, thanks for posting that link.
ESPN shows tonight’s game “postponed.” No info on ajd.com.
Wednesday and Thursday canceled. Double header (I presume as needed) on Monday. Nightmare.
https://www.mlb.com/news/mets-braves-september-25-26-games-rescheduled
The Padres & the Brewers gotta be loving this revolting development.
Seems the Mets will miss Sale & Fried completely now.
And our potential WC rotation? (Best-case: Sale would be available for Game 2 on 4-days’ rest.)
What a strange way to finish a regular season… talk about bad luck.
I think you have to start Sale and Fried in our next 2 games against the Royals. Those games against the Mets on Monday are not guaranteed to matter. And if the team can make the playoffs, then Sale and Fried are lined up to go in Games 2 and 3.
Go Giants and Padres!
And go Royals the next 2 nights vs. the Nats.
Maybe they clinch their WC spot before we play them.
Joel Sherman in the NY Daily News on the DH situation:
https://nypost.com/2024/09/25/sports/how-braves-decision-for-mets-series-set-up-nightmare-hurricane-helene-scenario/
100%. Play to win the next game. This might be a blessing in disguise. It doesn’t feel like it but let’s see how it shakes out
In addition to rooting for the Giants and Padres, and the Royals tonight and tomorrow, you can also root against the Royals’ WC competition (Tigers, Twins, Mariners) the rest of the way. AND root for the Brewers, and against the Phils and Dodgers (if Milwaukee and San Diego are close enough to Philly/LA to possibly get a bye, they’ll play harder against the Mets and D-backs).
Whew, that’s some 3-dimensional chess scoreboard watching, lol.
Grounds crew will have to bust it to even play Friday.
So this is basically the opposite of the past two post-season starts where the Braves had multiple days off, which did not go too well.
Who knows, maybe this will keep them to stay hot – assuming they get in, of course.
If you can’t get out of it, get into it. Go Braves!
The Athletic spells out the possible playoff scenarios.
https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/5796493/2024/09/26/national-league-wild-card-mlb-playoffs-possibilities/
Who doesn’t love an exciting September finish?
Who are starting the KC series? The on-line services have Fried going tomorrow, not Sale, then Morton and Holmes. Can that possibly be correct? Did Sale come up with a sore arm or something?
Snit said today that they are saving Sale for an elimination game. (Lol wut?!)
We’re either really dumb, or Sale is kinda hurt or something. Why pitch your best starter twice in the next week when you can…wait for it…pitch him only once?
If Kenny Powers starts this weekend I’m going to lose it.
Sale must be hurting. If an “elimination game” isn’t until Monday (highly possible since Sale will not be starting the against the Royals, a good team with something to play for), that takes him completely out of the Wild Card series if the Braves make it. That’s really either more bad luck for the team this year or a true head-scratcher.
I think Snit is waiting to see if he has to pitch Sale. I don’t agree with it, but his reasoning probably goes that the Royals will have little to play for after the Twins choke away this thing (more on that historic collapse another time). We can possibly sweep the Royals without pitching Sale and maybe have a doubleheader against the Mets where we only have to win one. In that scenario, you hold Sale for game 2 I guess and if it’s not necessary, you start him game 1 of WC.
And here’s more from the Athletic on how we got into this mess:
https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/5795093/2024/09/25/mets-braves-weather-delay/
Watching the Twins in the 12th against the gNats. It is amusing to me that a relief pitcher named Blewett has neither a hold nor a save in his career.
And…. he takes the loss.
Rosenthal on how Monday’s doubleheader could affect other teams in the Wild Card race.
https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/5798478/2024/09/27/mets-braves-doubleheader-wild-card-brewers-padres-negatives/
How’s the situation for you guys living around Atlanta. Hope everyone is staying safe.
Will a game be possible today at all?
Atlanta has been hit hard–downed trees, lots of power outages, major creek flooding. But the rain is ending now, so Truist should be in good shape for the game tonight. I believe the drainage there is excellent.
Sale has to be hurt.
Hope everyone is staying safe.
Could be as simple as “gassed.” Sale hasn’t thrown this many innings in the better part of a decade. At this point, Snit’s going to be making some game-time decisions, and one of them might be Lopez, too.
Royals are in the WC with either 1 win or 1 Twins loss. So we can pull for the Orioles to go ahead and put the Twins out of their misery tonight, and maybe KC will rest a few players and relax a bit Saturday and Sunday.
Of course the flip side to that is that the Padres can no longer catch the Dodgers, and as soon as they beat the Dbacks one time, they’re locked into the top WC spot. And it looks like the Brewers, who play the Mets this weekend, are locked into their spot too. Maybe they’ll all be internally motivated to still play their best and help us out…
Starting pitching sucks against the royals. And now no Sale. Pray Lopez comes back for the Mets, because I really do not want to see Morton and Holmes pitching in important games.
MURPHY!! What a great trade for him!