For the second offseason in a row, the Braves invested a decently high amount of money in a corner outfielder in his 30s. Just so we’re clear, I loved the Profar deal; I like the Yaz deal. So, take the below for what you will.
Frankly, there are probably fewer words to say here, though I will likely natter on too long anyway: the years aren’t that long, the dollars aren’t that high, and while the guy is getting older, he’s been quite consistently effective as a two-win hitter. For a team whose last two seasons have hinged on our abysmal lack of depth, he’s a nice piece. He’s not a game-changer, and this contract may not be the most cost-effective way of acquiring two wins, but we needed a guy like him, and now we’ve got him.
As Ben Clemens wrote at Fangraphs: “Clearly, then the Braves wanted this veteran outfielder and thought they couldn’t risk waiting to see if he would sign with them for less.”
Still, good player. Glad we have him.
So, it’s essentially a three-year deal for $26 million, or they can save $3 million by cutting him after year two. He’s already 35, and he’ll turn 38 in August of 2028, but frankly, given the small amount of additional money, I think there’s a decent chance we pick up the option unless is value goes into negative territory in year 2.
So, Mike Yastrzemski has a famous last name, but that’s really it. He went to St. John’s Prep, a Catholic high school in Danvers, MA not particularly known for its baseball program. Mike was the third graduate of the school to be selected in the draft, but all were low picks and none signed. When his grandfather’s team, the Boston Red Sox, selected him in the 36th round of the 2009 draft, he declined their charity and went to college.
(Six years before Mike, the Dodgers tried to draft Matt Antonelli out of St. John’s Prep in the 19th round. But Antonelli declined, opted for college at Wake Forest, and later became a first round pick, and ultimately a prospect bust.)
Yastrzemski got a baseball scholarship to Vanderbilt, which is nothing to sneeze at, but while he made the SEC Academic Honor roll each year from 2011-2013, he only really got athletic accolades his senior year, when he was named First Team All-SEC, Second Team All-South, and Third Team All-American. You get where I’m going with this: he’s got bloodlines and makeup, and he’s a hard worker, not a toolshed.
He was a senior sign out of Vanderbilt, taken by the Orioles in the 14th round of the draft, a college senior out of Vanderbilt with zero leverage; the previous year, the Mariners selected him in the 30th round. He spent the rest of 2013 and the 2014 season in the low minors, where he did fairly well, and made it to the upper minors for good in 2015, and spent the next three years shuttling between Double-A Bowie and Triple-A Norfolk.
In all, he spent six years in the Baltimore farm system, hitting .260/.337/.428 while mostly playing corner outfield, and clearly they didn’t see a place for him on the major league roster, trading him to the Giants in 2019 for an organizational pitcher named Tyler Herb who never made the majors.
The Giants sent him to Triple-A, where he immediately started hitting, and they finally gave him his callup three months before his 29th birthday, and he rewarded them by being worth about 2.5 wins a year for seven seasons before free agency. He plays adequate defense in the outfield, has a good walk rate and decent power, though his overall hitting stats may be somewhat muted by playing half his games in one of the more extreme pitchers’ parks in the majors in San Francisco.
He hits for a low average, which suppresses his walk rate; last year, he had a noticeable dip in his power, too. His fielding is fine for a corner, but he only spent a handful of innings in center last year, so he wouldn’t be more than emergency depth out there. Due to his long stay in the minor leagues, he has fewer miles on his knees than many his age – he’s only played 20 more games in the majors and 200 more games in the minors than Austin Riley, though he’s seven years older.
As Ben Clemens points out in his piece at Fangraphs, the Braves are paying more for Mike Yastrzemski than other teams have paid other players who seem roughly comparable — Adolis Garcia and Cedric Mullins took one-year deals, and Miguel Andujar and Willi Castro are still available. So the Braves pounced quickly and arguably paid a little more than they had to because they wanted this specific player.
It’s easy to point out the things to like: he’s been very consistent, he’s very well-liked, he clearly deserves a lot of respect as a hard worker and a grinder who has achieved far beyond what his modest draft status and prospect profile would have suggested. Also, the Braves front office has several refugees from Farhan Zaidi’s front office in San Francisco, most notably AGM Pete Putila, and it’s quite likely that they loudly advocated that AA target him in particular.
The downside risk is also easy to see: he’s getting older, he’s striking out more, and his power just dipped last year.
He’s probably going to be a glue guy, which is something that the clubhouse appeared to lack last year, as injuries contributed to a growing malaise. He’s not going to be able to produce more than complementary value. But he’s a nice player. I’m glad he’s on our side.

Thanks Alex, that’s a more balanced assessment than my first reaction.
I go back to my belief that you don’t win by signing a bunch of guys under value, you win by signing a bunch of guys under value so that you can overpay to get what you need to win. That is something we haven’t done in a while.
Paradoxically, if the Braves think they overpaid for Yaz it’s probably a good move, if they think he’s worth what they paid, then he’s probably going to be given too great a role for this stage of his career.
As George Patton once said, no baseball team ever won a division by signing a bunch of guys under value. They won it by making the other poor dumb baseball teams sign a bunch of guys under value.
Love Patton on baseball!
I mostly agree, except Yaz is definitely not striking out more. As I mentioned the other day, his 19% K rate in 2025 was by far the best of his career. His 13% walk rate was close to his career best. His ISO dipped a bit, but that was due to a a rough start to the season in SF. After he was traded to KCR, his ISO soared to .263 in about a third of a season of work. That would be nearly a career best.
Betting on a 35 year old to improve seems like folly, but there is a lot to like from those trends and going to a park that suits his strengths.
Yaz is basically Nick Markakis. Per WAR, he’s worth the contract he got. But the number just seems high. Of course, you can pay a guy with one more WAR $30M a year and no one bats an eye. It’s weird how the guys making $12-20M get evaluated.
This is something I’ve observed for years. It seems like the 2-3 WAR guys are a market inefficiency. The 7 WAR guys are sometimes underpaid per WAR. The worst seems to be the Bo Bichettes. They get paid $30 million for 4 WAR.
This may of course all be in my head. Sounds like a good project for JonathanF
It’s almost like you have tiers:
-2-3 WAR guys will make around $5-6M per WAR.
-3-4 WAR guys will make around $8-9M per WAR.
-5+ WAR guys will make around $5-6M per WAR.
Obviously these are huge generalities.
I would assume Kim will be a 3 WAR guy, and so he kinda slides into that $6M-per-WAR ratio, and people thought it was an overpay.
Saurez is a 2 WAR guy, and he’ll be paid around $6M per WAR.
Iglesisas is a little over-paid by this metric.
Yaz is right there.
But Bichette, probably at best, is a 4 WAR player, and he’ll be paid around $30 this year. I’m not sure I see why you would do that.
He pulls the ball, and pulls it in the air, and has played his entire career in a park that punishes him for doing that. Truist should reward him, instead. Some upside there.
I did see a graphic going around that his slugging on fastballs is declining year over year. That might make you regret the length of the deal.
As far as defensive quality of our outfield, I’d rank them Harris, Eli White (who can’t hit) Dubon, Yaz, Acuna, Profar… Couple that fact with Dubon’s career .762 OPS vs lefties and Yaz’s .802 vs righties, I think in the rare event that everyone is healthy, Profar will be DHing quite a bit and Dubon/Yaz will platoon in LF.
If injury or ineffectiveness presses Dubon in to something like everyday infield duty, we better hope Murphy eventually return to health and effectiveness, so he can take over the lefty-masher side of a much more complicated virtual platoon where Murphy catches, Baldwin DHs, and Profar plays LF in order to keep Yaz from starting against lefties.
Braves sign Ian Hamilton, who has spent the last 4 years with the Yankees, to a non-guaranteed contract. He has a career 3.59 ERA and 3.64 FIP. He’s stuck out over a batter an inning.
To compare to Pierce Johnson, Johnson has a career 3.79 ERA and 3.72 FIP, striking out a little over a batter an inning.
Tyler Kinley has rough career numbers due to spending so much time in Colorado, but I think what Atlanta clearly didn’t like about Kinley is that he doesn’t strike out nearly as many batters. Kinley struck out less than a better per inning last year even with his 0.74 ERA.
So Atlanta thought they were getting something pretty similar to Johnson and Kinley for a non-guaranteed, pretty much contract. I would assume Hamilton is a replacement for Kinley or even Johnson for pennies on the dollar.
Maybe it’s just me, but “Ian Hamilton” sounds more like the lead singer of a Canadian rock band than he sounds like a right-handed reliever. I am going to forget his handedness approximately once a day.
We have a lot of arms that might figure in the pen. I doubt Hamilton is one of them. Kinley and Johnson were fine but not likely to move the needle and not worth paying $12 million for the pair, especially with Johnson’s declining K rate. Kinley I wouldn’t mind trying to bring back at a lower number.
I am still worried about the bullpen depth, particularly if JJ cannot return. We just don’t have anybody with options who has shown MLB relief capabilities other than Daysbel. The system can’t seem to develop relievers, and we are relying on a large group of question marks to produce a few we can depend on. If that doesn’t pan out or we have a few injuries, you’re back cruising for a Montero on the waiver wire.
Maybe some of Hayden Harris, Lucas Braun, and Blake Burkhalter can add to that group of guys who can be called upon. Suarez and Payamps were clever acquisitions who might play a significant role. It should be one of the more interesting springs trying to figure out how the staff shakes out.
You would have to assume that this would be the year they start sending guys to the pen earlier than usual. The rotation is largely full, and a prospect would have to be really good to play his way into the rotation. And on almost every list you look at, 60-70% of our top prospects are starting pitchers. Something will have to give. Otherwise, what’s the point of stacking your farm with SPs if you’re not going to do anything with them?
Someone said before that future SP should be broken in as relievers (like Max was). I have to wonder if there’s some thinking that JR or Jhancarlos or Lucas or Didier or someone else might be used as relievers in addition to the ones mentioned above. There’s also some buzz that Karinchak might be useful.
IIRC, Ian Hamilton was the bass player for April Wine (or Barenaked Ladies).
Indiana -7 vs. Alabama in the Rose Bowl… hysterical.
Really should be Bama -7.
Alright, just for shits and gigs, what would be the package Atlanta would have to give up to get Skubal? I’ll give it a shot: Waldrep, Ritchie, Lodise, and Braun. I could see needing to upgrade Ritchie to Caminiti. And that would be incredibly steep for one year of a guy, but flags fly forever, and we have a tooooon of pitching prospects we could give up.
That is about right. I personally do not want to give up Waldrep in any trade, save for a young, controllable player, because he projects to be core starter for several years. I wouldn’t trade Caminiti and Ritchie for a 1-year rental, and I don’t think AA will do it either. We aren’t 1 pitcher away from a title. A Skubal trade might take us from an 8% shot to a 12% shot going into the season, hardly a guaranteed flag. Now if Skubal will sign something like an 8-year, $224 million extension, I would be willing to trade our top prospects. I don’t think he will because he has reportedly asked for $400 million. And if we were going to spend that for a pitcher, why in God’s name didn’t we just sign Fried and keep our prospects?
The Braves’ TV rights could soon revert back to the team:
https://awfulannouncing.com/local-networks/fanduel-sports-networks-shutter-dazn-sale.html?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=twitter
Jeff McNeil traded to the As.
He always seemed to have the Braves number…or is it just me?
Yup, there was a time when he was the last Met I’d wanna see hitting in a big spot… but now? Vanquished to Siberia (i.e., Sacramento).
The Mets continue to disassemble, or at least jettison Lindor’s non-friends (excluding Soto, of course).
Curious to see how much inner-Steinbrenner Uncle Steve summons this winter.