“If you want it, you got it, Just bust a move.” Young MC came to mind today and I wish he was right. But “you want it, you got it” rarely happens.
In fact, it is next to never that Young MC’s notion comes to pass in my life! I bet the same is true for you. And, unfortunately, the results from our “Who would you rather…?” game shoot the young rapper’s lyrics full of holes, too.
You would rather…play the Marlins
When choosing the NLDS opponent for the Braves, 96% of Braves Journal readers would rather play the Fish. When choosing between Miami and the Philthies, the choice was overwhelming. Unfortunately for Braves Journalers, its getting late in Game 2 and the Fish are flopping around and apparently out of water. Aaron Nola has wiggled out of trouble on a couple of occasions and I’m already sick of the gorilla gyrations.
…beat the Philthies
Again, Braves Journalers where united as 92% want to beat the Philthies. Philly is more of a rivalry, and they are far more unlikeable than the Fish. These two facts alone make me wonder why this wasn’t 100% of the vote. And then if you throw in Jorge Soler losing a playoff game to the Braves apparently feels like more than we can bear. Hopefully, Young MC is right here and we can bust a move with a 3-1 series win over those Philthy Philthies!
You would rather…see Max Fried start Game One

I wish Snit had called yesterday before the open-to-the-fans scrimmage. But, alas, he didn’t – and Max Fried threw 76 pitches against the B-team. It was good to hear that Sean Murphy and Kevin Pillar launched missiles against a great pitcher. But, the fact that Max gave up two homers has some in Braves Country concerned. Unfortunately, the 67% of us who wanted Max to start Game One will probably not be busting any moves. Fried is the likely Game Two starter. The good news is we have Spencer Strider to make the Game One start. Let’s hope he is dialed in!
You would rather…see AJ Smith-Shawver be the third starter

When choosing between Bryce Elder, AJ Smith-Shawver, and Jesse Chavez being our third starter, opinions are mixed. Smith-Shawver received 46% of the votes, followed by Elder (29%) and Chavez (25%). It is like that Kyle Wright will follow up any of these three, depending on their effectiveness. And word out of yesterday’s simulated game reported that Smith-Shawver didn’t give up a hit in five innings against the best lineup in baseball…without Marcell OHzuna in the lineup, that is.

Thanks for playing along. We shall see how Snit manages the team and how what we would rather see plays itself out early next week. Playing the Fish would have been easier, but I really want the Braves to stick it to the Philthies and am glad they will get them in the next round. It sounds like the bats were solid again today in the pre-NLDS scrimmage. Word out of Truist is that Ronald Acuña Jr., Travis d’Arnaud, and OHzuna all homered twice, while Austin Riley also hit a missile.
The NLDS is gonna be high-drama, must-see TV. And here’s the thing, I would much rather be the Braves than the Philthies. Beat those Philtie dogs, boys, and let’s bust a move into the NLCS!
Thanks for this Christian. Reading it makes me start to get anxious for game 1. Go Braves!
Game 1, 6:07 pm Saturday (TBS)
Game 2, 6:07 pm Monday (TBS)
Games 3-5, still TBD
I was hoping selfishly for one earlier start but this is great for Truist and the Braces.
I am shocked with those starting times – and GRATEFUL!
I hope the guys are ready to rumble. I think last year none of the regulars were at their best (Acuna, Albies, and Ozuna especially). Whether we score early or late, this team is more ready to win than last year’s. Unlike the All Star break where 8 Braves had to travel and play, I’m hoping these last few days were much more relaxing.
I know I shouldn’t come here expecting free therapy, but . . . I live in the Philly area, and after the local team’s resounding win over the Fish, the Phaithful are positively full of themselves. The university where I work encouraged faculty, staff, and students to don their Phillies gear the rest of the week. That, I don’t mind. It’s all in good fun.
But the obnoxious arrogance is definitely getting under my skin. They are all ABSOLUTELY SURE that their team is going to dispense with the Braves and roll to the World Series. My somewhat weak response so far has been, “Don’t be so sure. The Braves mash and Strider is going to be out for vengeance in Game 1. Good luck hitting that 99 MPH fastball, followed by an 87 MPG changeup. Oh, and if the Phils do manage to get lucky and beat Atlanta, it mostly just proves that 104 wins doesn’t mean nearly as much as it used to.” They harumph and walk away. Meanwhile, behind my calm visage, by blood pressure spikes.
I hope what I’m saying about Strider–which I don’t 100 percent believe–turns out to be the truth. Or at least close to it . . .
I’m happy to oblige the cry for help, Mark. I wonder if this might help…use or toss anything and everything I say if it is not helpful!
When I am not stirred up and in my best thinking spaces, it has been helpful to adopt a principle that I learned from Brené Brown…she poses a question that goes something like this: “What if people aren’t sucking on purpose just to piss me off?” When I can stop and ask this question, I can get to a place of compassion for people – even the Philthie Phaithful!
I like to say once you’ve seen it you can’t unsee it. You get to decide if this nugget is helpful or not, or if you want to try it on or not. And I have a lot of compassion for you having to be around so many Philthie phans!
Aren’t we very very worried about Sean Murphy’s horrible second half and even more horrible last month of the season? If Snit continues to hit Harris in the six or seven spot in the lineup, there will be absolutely no production at the bottom of the order (Arcia hasn’t been much better than Murphy lately). With two holes at the bottom of the order, it is unlikely that the Braves will be able to score the five or six runs a game they’ll need to win this series. (What happened to Murphy after the All-Star break?)
Yeah, Doug, it was a rough second half for both of the Braves catchers, if we’re honest. I wonder how much of that is tied to sharing so much of the load and neither being able to get into a rhythm. Last year, Travis got most of the catching reps and I wonder if Sean will get most of them this post-season with all the off-days in between. Before yesterday, I believed that would be the case – but then Travis went and had a two-homer game in the simulated scrimimmage (see the Ridiculous 6 on Netflix for reference) and may have muddied the waters for Snit.
I like Money Mike in the nine-hole, personally – but if we’re gonna have two holes in the lineup as you point out, it is tough for a manager to know how to handle it. Kill a rally? Or wait til you get back to the top to initiate one? Either way, most night’s we are still going to get out 5-6 runs and I think we will be just fine!
People are concerned about rust from a week off, and rightly so. But don’t discount rest, particularly for a catcher. Recovery for Murphy is not at all unlikely. The easiest prediction is that there will be performances we don’t expect, both good and bad.
Truth, Johnathan. I can’t wait to see who surprises me. Maybe Eddie can go off like he did in ’21.
Murphy’s hot start gave us a wildly inflated opinion of who he is. He still finished the season with a career year, just more in line with his usual performance than he tempted us with. He’s still one of the better hitting catchers, just not really a middle of the order guy.
I don’t know if I mentioned this, but I really can’t stand that Alec Bohm. He still never touched home.
I will be rooting hard for my Braves, as I always do, but I’m always prepared for disappointment. If I were a betting person, I would put my money on the Phillies if I got 2:1 odds. Their pitching is not necessarily better than ours, but it sure seems like their 2 aces are big game pitchers. Maybe that’s a real thing and maybe it’s not. Maybe it’s more luck. Fried sure can be, but Strider hasn’t shown that yet.
The Phillies rebuilt when we did and didn’t do nearly so well in the draft and trades, so they bought their team, mostly, and they did very well at that. There were 5 different 8 figure contracts that they shelled out for free agents (Realmuto, Castellano, Wheeler, Harper, Turner). We shelled out none. Zach Wheeler is one of the best free agent signings in major league history. I sure wish we had found a way to bring home the Smyrna boy, but we opted for Cole Hamels if memory serves. And for the 4th year in a row, we wonder if we have enough starters for a playoff series. It feels a lot better to have a home grown team, but I would feel a lot better if we just went and signed an ace for once.
You have mentioned that, stampton, and I am with you. I’m not a Bohm fan, either. I love the way AA has constructed this team and as I look around at all of the free agent pitching signings in recent years, the only ones that have been decent are Wheeler and Gerrit Cole.
I’d rather have Harris hit 9th and the holes be at 7/8 or 6/7. That way if the guys in the holes really do something it’s followed by Harris and the top of the lineup and if they don’t then Harris and Acuna lead off.
I wonder if it’s time to consider platooning Arcia and Lopez. According to BRef Lopez’s defense is better and Arcia is terrible against righties (and absolutely mashes lefties). I think Arcia’s splits are the biggest on the team. The idea of pinch hitting Arcia against a lefty reliever is really nice.
Not loving the Saturday start time — guess I’ll have to turn the living room into a sports bar — but I do like the idea of Strider & Fried potentially starting 4 games, all on regular rest.
Odd Fact: The Braves hitter with the most success off Zach Wheeler is Travis d’Arnaud. In 23 PA, he’s 8 for 21 w/ 2 BB, 1 2B & 1 HR, for a .381/.435/.571 slash line.
Most HRs: Acuna w/ 4 HR in 47 PA.
If TdA starts, 5 of our 9 guys in the lineup are hitting under .200 against him. (Eg. – In 49 PA, Ozuna’s OPS is .544 w/ 17 Ks)
Also, of note: The Phils team OPS vs. Strider is .504.
In the regular season vs. Pha, he’s been super-dominant with a 38.4% K rate & a .06 BB rate (only 10 BBs w/ 5 to Schwarber). Marsh, who’s 4 for 11, is the only one w/ good numbers against him.
Let’s knock these guys out.
The Braves have been able to beat up on all the Philly starters but it comes down to bullpens. Philly wins all came from beating up the Braves bullpen. Strider won convincingly three times. Fried pitched once and gave up one run in 6 innings only to have the bullpen falter. Elder started one win and one loss. But the Braves have been able to beat both Wheeler and Nola.
Let’s knock these guys out, indeed! I think we win in 4.
And in other news… Mets GM Billy Eppler has resigned.
LOFREAKINGL
Dysfunction! Disorder!
I loved the story that came out the other day, where Buck Showalter revealed that Eppler forced him to play slumping DH Daniel Vogelbach against his wishes. (Winning over Mets fans after he’s already out the door…)
Also, in his exit interview w/ Eppler, Buck apparently called the Mets analytics team “a bunch of cymbal-clanging monkees.”
Once again, it seems the Mets have smashed the reset button.
Now I know what to get my favorite Mets fans for Christmas:
Monkey Cymbals GIFfrom Monkey GIFs
https://tenor.com/embed.js
I am surrounded by Philly fans up here in south Jersey. But it’s my fault for marrying a Jersey Girl.
Objectively, I like the Phillies org and they’ve built a roster that is made for October. Braves are a deeper, better roster and the BEST org in MLB. So they win more games over 162. In a five-game series, much closer.
I love Truist. But CBP is louder when rocking. I do believe the experience of past year helps us not be intimidated when we come back to Philly for Game 3.
I’m not that worried about Game 1. But the series hinges on Game 2. Wheeler is a Big Game pitcher. I do like that we roughed him up a little last month in Atlanta. And I like we get him again at home. But Braves need to win both games in Atlanta. I do not like our chances to win BOTH games in Philly if we must.
Think about this: after having the best lineup and the best record this year, anything less than a WS championship is a disappointment for the Braves. Expectations couldn’t be higher. Does that become too much pressure?
I had linked to the Showalter exit interview thing in a comment that’s currently the last one at The Bar.
Worth noting: the “cymbal-clanging monkeys” comment was fabricated by a joke Twitter account, someone pretending to be Mets beat writer Anthony DiComo.
My aim wasn’t to help spread fake news, but rather, to point out that former Mets GM Ruben Amaro, Jr. apparently fell for the joke and did an earnest tweet bashing the Mets’ analytics team. Chef’s kiss.
Anyway, there’s now a real Mets front office controversy to focus on, if you so choose.
When legend becomes fact, print the legend.
I just realized that the streaming service I used to watch the Braves’ regular season games this year (FuboTV) doesn’t carry TBS, which is where the NLDS and NLCS will both be broadcast. I’m thinking of doing a free trial of Hulu TV and possibly YouTube TV after that.
Does anyone have any experience with these streaming services? Any recommendations for other ways to stream these games?
I have used YouTubeTV for years. It was once an amazing bargain; now, not so much. (I still save vis-a-vis cable because I use the same service in two houses, but otherwise cable would now be cheaper… I think.) But it works fine.
But according to this https://www.mlb.com/live-stream-games/postseason/2023providers FuboTV subscribers can get all the MLB postseason on mlb.tv for $25.
Can’t really speak for cable prices in your area… but my experience w/ Hulu has been fine. Watching the “DVR’d” content is a little weird, but I like how easy it is to watch on other devices & they do have some content (sports & otherwise) I don’t have on my regular cable service.
When we had the big Spectrum cable scare this past August (my area is Spectrum, of course), I couldn’t bear the thought of no college football beyond Week 1, so I signed up for one of those Hulu intro deals. (What? Like I’m going to miss any of the UGA/Ball St. game?)
Of course, Spectrum came back after about 2 weeks, so now I have both – I’ll keep the Hulu until the college-football season is over or I run out of yet-unseen music documentaries.
And yes, it has TBS.
Thanks, JonathanF! I’ll definitely check this out. I didn’t realize this was an option. Since I’m already a Fubo subscriber, getting the MLB TV add-on would be the most sensible course of action.
I completely understand, ububba. We die-hard sports fans will go to great lengths to watch our favorite teams. I got rid of cable years ago and became a Hulu customer (and had a pleasant experience), but switched to Fubo when I discovered that Hulu would no longer be carrying the Bally Sports regional networks.
Fubo isn’t exactly cheap, but I watch every Braves game plus other sporting events/shows, so to me it’s worth it. I do wish that MLB would make games more accessible, though.
The plot thickens: turns out Eppler resigned because MLB is about to crack down on the “phantom IL.”
https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/38577028/billy-eppler-quits-general-manager-new-york-mets
AA might want to keep his head on a swivel.
So it looks like Daysbel Hernandez made the roster; Wright and Chavez did not. So I would assume the latter are just not healthy. I think Hernandez can do fine in a multi-inning, save-the-pitching situation. Hopefully we don’t need multi high-leverage, multi-inning guys.
Uck. I was hoping Wright would be around this series. He made me feel better about game 3.
Braves in 3!
Remaining NLDS schedule:
Game 3: Wednesday, 10/11, 5:07 p.m., TBS, TruTV
*Game 4: Thursday, 10/12, 6:07 p.m., TBS, TruTV
*Game 5: Saturday, 10/14, 6:07 p.m., TBS, TruTV