A Note On Scoring Runs

I looked at every game played this year as of last night. It will surprise no one that winning is positively related to scoring runs. But I was a little surprised at just how related it is. Here are the winning percentage across all teams by runs scored:

Runs ScoredWinning Percentage
00
111%
227%
342%
452%
568%
674%

I have to say I was somewhat surprised that scoring one run had even as high as an 11% probability. But this year there have indeed been 35 1-0 games this year and 276 games with the losing team scoring only run. It only seems like these were all Braves games. The Braves have won no 1-0 games this year, but have lost 5 2-1 and 3 3-1 games, and 5 other games in which they scored only 1 run. That’s 13 1-run games, all losses.

The good teams have scored one run around seven times. You need to score runs to win.

The Game

Aaron Bummer, in his first career start, confounded his critics with five strikeouts in his first two innings of work. He then proceeded to confound his supporters (like his manager, who sent him back out there in the 3rd) by giving up two homers and three runs to cough up a lead which he had gotten courtesy of a two-run Austin Riley homer in the 1st. Bummer confounds everyone! His starting ERA ought to be somewhere between his first two inning ERA of 0.00 and his 3rd inning ERA of 81.00. No wonder it’s confounding.

Matt Olson counfounded Dean Kremer‘s plan with a tying home run in the bottom of the third. Kremer didn’t want to throw a slider to Olson, but he overruled himself: he lost the battle of Kremer vs. Kremer.

Dylan Dodd, in the best shape of his career, finished up the two outs in the third successffully and was given the fourth. Colton Cowser hit a two-run confounder to give the Orioles the lead back.

Not for long, as the Kremer Confoundment continued. (That was the title of the last unfinished work by Robert Ludlum.) Hits from Olson and Riley brought in two more runs to tie it at 5-5. The Braves rallied in the bottom of the the 5th but were forced to give an at-bat under the rules of baseball to Michael Harris II, the Braves’ designated non-hitter.

The 6th saw Scott Blewitt confounding expectations by pitching the 6th against his old team. Unlike Charlie Morton yesterday, he was not given a standing ovation on his return to Truist. I guess fans are just not sufficiently grateful for his storied six-week career in a Braves uniform. The fans changed their tune, however, when Blewitt promptly loaded the bases: they like him now! A Jurickson Profar dribbler gave the Braves the lead.

Austin Cox saw the mandatory minimum three batters in the 7th. Only one of them scored! So we’re tied again.

The 9th inning began with Raisel Iglesias on the mound. It’s a bullpen game, and he’s in the bullpen, right? Actually, he has pitched much better since he lost the closer role. That’s great, except that sometimes you need a closer. But I’d much rather have an effective set-up guy and no real closer than a bad closer.

Felix Bautista pitched the 9th for Earl Weaver‘s boys. We cleared his bullpen spot to get to Manfred Man time. Rafael Montero pitched, if you call it that, and gave up three. The decision to play the infield in with a Manfred Man on third and one out backfired in the way that play usually does, when it backfires: you increase the chance of cutting down the run at the expense of opening up the possibility of a big inning. I’m not a fan…. I would rather cede the run knowing that you’ll have a reasonable chance on the other side, but I acknowledge it’s a close call. Indeed, a recent Fangraphs article by Ben Clemens argues that the home team has an extra innings disadvantage under the Manfred Man rules for just this reason.

Referencing the chart above, we scored 6 and still lost. But at least we didn’t lose by one.

In any case, we still had a chance, but it’s hard to argue that you have a great chance of scoring three in an inning in which Michael Harris II is due to hit. Yennier Cano pitched to Ozzie Albies, Harris II and Luke Willams — should that even count as a save? The only thing you saved was the embarrassment of giving up a hit to those guys. Had any one gotten on, RAJ would have had a chance. He didn’t.

My Misspent Youth

Does anyone other than me remember The King and Odie? Confound it! Why am I doomed to remember this crap?